Monday, May 14, 2012

Writing about writing about research.



I suppose it was inevitable that someone would publish a scientific paper about blogs that write about scientific publications. That’s either very meta, or a little myopic, or both. Appropriately then, the paper “Research Blogs and the Discussion of Scholarly Information” is published in PLoS ONE, the most prominent open access journal. The internet has expanded scientific discourse beyond the traditional forms of published media, and blogs tend to provide a less formal, more accessible form of communication. The authors were particularly interested in how discussion of published works on research blogs related to the citation of published works in the traditional published literature. When we discuss and cite papers in blogs, those citations are meaningless in the traditional sense, in that they aren’t incorporated into citation analyses.

The authors used the blog aggregator ResearchBlogging.org to identify well-established science blogs. They surveyed 126 blogs, recording the names and fields of journals of the 10 most recently reviewed articles on each blog. They also recorded general information about the blog author(s). Life sciences were by far the most common area blogged about (39% of blogs), although life sciences account for only 21% of all publications. Given the fact that women now receive similar numbers of life science degrees, it is perhaps surprising that the vast majority of blogs have male authors (~67% have a single male author, and ~9% have multiple authors, at least one of which is male).

Regardless of who authors the blogs, the papers that are cited in blogs are predominantly from the highest profile journals – Science, Nature, and PNAS. These journals all have expensive paywalls for non-subscribers. The fourth most cited journal, by contrast, is PLoS ONE. It’s hard to say what this means. It may just be that Science, Nature, and PNAS are well represented in their sample because they are interdisciplinary, and so many blogs will cite them. Or, it may be that bloggers are attracted to the same types of papers that Science and Nature are – high profile, “important”, maybe controversial. Further, bloggers may write about high profile papers, but they do so with greater depth and knowledge than most mainstream media.

There’s only so much that you can draw from a relatively small, simple survey, but some of the trends seem contrary to the supposed openness and accessibility of web-based science communication. Research blogs are written primarily by men, and focus on high-profile, non-open access papers. Does the open-access nature of a blog overcome the non-open access nature of the papers they write about? Does writing about a Science paper make the information within it accessible to more people, or does it decrease the number of people who can fully appreciate your post? Ultimately research blogging is complex, like any form of online media; it can improve on traditional communication while still showing some of the same limitations. It does bode well though that, given the number of blogs commenting on this paper, research bloggers tend to be informed and pretty self-aware.


43 comments:

Devin said...

Classic, you are blogging about a scientific publication about blogs that write about scientific publications. This is like a scene out of Airplane (also like an experience I had while riding in a buggy in Amish country, but that's another story).

I just took a really fast look at the paper, but the focus is rather peculiar. The demographics of bloggers is mildly interesting, but maybe not the most relevant aspect to science. To me the most interesting question is how does blogging impact the citation of a paper? That is, if someone writes a favourable blog about a paper, does this increased visibility translate to a higher citation rate?

Caroline Tucker said...

It's a rather unfocused paper, I totally agree. I think science blogging is interesting (I have to!), but this paper doesn't really explore the more important and/or measurable aspects of that.

Hans Castorp said...

I'm afraid the paper is all too right; many (not every) ecological blogs are rather supportive to ecological conformism. It is difficult to be surprised reading them. I think the problem is not lack of good will, but the fact that currently we are too much concerned with problems of "general interest", and it is very difficult to say something interesting about such problems.

Cathyee lyones said...

Your article is very informative. I have learnt many things from you. Thanks for sharing your idea with us. Actually i have searched online for writing services to write my term papers but now i have got many useful idea from you .

sneha said...

Took me time to read all the comments, but I really enjoyed the article. It proved to be Very useful to me and I am sure to all the commenter here! It's always nice when you can not only be informed, but also entertained! I'm sure you had fun writing this article.
writing research essay

Gurdeep Kaurbti said...

resume editing service A resume should demonstrate your professional abilities and professional competence as well as your personal confidence and our expert resume editing service can help make sure your resume is of the highest quality. We provide you with an editor who is experienced with resume editing and will focus on your documents to help you shine among the other applicants. Our resume editing services know that the first impression a potential employer may have of you, is through your resume and the goal of our resume editing service is to make you stand out in your resume.

Gurdeep Kaurbti said...

custom writing How do you get your thesis paper done on time? Do you need assistance to finish it? If you do, then you have come to the right page. Here at Qatar Thesis Writing Service

somali music said...

i need help writing a business plan many people put together flawed business plans without even knowing it. One option that some don’t consider is help writing a business plan, and by getting help you are giving your business a better shot.

Gurdeep Kaurbti said...

yahoo password recovery The reason is maybe you forgot your yahoo password or your account is hacked. It is really annoying when such thing happens. What should you do? Is it possible to perform yahoo password recovery? Yes, there are some ways you can choose.

Gurdeep Kaurbti said...

link building service With over 11 years of experience, we bring you all SEO, Content Writing, and Link Building Service under one roof.

Gurdeep Kaurbti said...

non plagiarized term papers We offer non plagiarized term papers, non plagiarized research papers, and non plagiarized essays to fulfill your needs. When you come to non-plagiarized.com, you will get help with whatever essay writing services that you may need.

hayda said...

That is very good comment you shared.Thank you so much that for you shared those things with us.Im wishing you to carry on with ur achivments.All the best. chat Mirc indir Sohbet Siteleri

somali music said...

Tucson Criminal Defense Janet Altschuler is Tucson's premier criminal defense attorney. Our practice focus is on domestic violence and drug crimes.

Gurdeep Kaurbti said...

cheap paper writing service If you are a student getting your degree, you must have a lot of troubles in your current life!

somali music said...

doctorate thesis Writing your doctorate thesis is a process which can take years of research and work, its simultaneously the most feared and most awaited part of an academic career, after all if you’ve made it to this point you probably have no problem with hard work.

Gurdeep Kaurbti said...

الدراسة اون لاين تقف مصر بحذر أمام موجة الانفتاح القوية في العالم للتعليم عن بعد ، فتتشدد في الاعتراف بأي جامعة خارجية ، و تطلب اعتمادا دوليا موثوقا .

All Escort Girls said...

All Escort Girls Prostitution is sometimes called "the oldest profession in the world" (a term first used by Rudyard Kipling in 1888 and taken over by the health professionals in the early twentieth century) *. Or a callgirl escort girl offers a meeting sexual nature or not on a call unlike practicing prostitutes on the street. The escort may receive the customer at home or move. The escort girls can be independent or exercised through an agency. Some escort girls say "luxury" can fly a fee and have an activity and a global reputation.

howiekisses said...

cheap knitwear No fancy packaging and costly branding that is destined for the bin just good quality products at rockbottom prices

Gurdeep Kaurbti said...

writing research paper

Gurdeep Kaurbti said...

masini second hand cutie automata · opel astra G · mercedes e · abs bosch · opel-astra · focus · ford focus. Copyright © 2012-2013 AutoZunk.ro. Contact - Termeni si Conditii.

Gurdeep Kaurbti said...

iphone unlock Australia trusts Fixpod as the Official Source for iPhone Unlocking, with the easiest and fastest online processing. Click NOW! unlock at&t iphone All requests for iPhone unlock must meet general iPhone unlock eligibility requirements before an iPhone can be unlocked. AT&T will unlock an iPhone under ... unlock iphone at&t AT&T Intellectual Property. All rights reserved. AT&T, the AT&T logo and all other AT&T marks contained herein are trade imei unlock Official Factory Unlock 4 any iPhone model. IMEI Unlocks are PERMANENT Unlocks for Any iPhone model, regardless of iOS version or Baseband. factory unlock JM Unlocks - Permanent OFFICIAL Factory Unlock (IMEI-based) for all iPhone models, all basebands and all firmwares. No jailbreak required. unlock iphone 5 Easily Unlock iPhone 5, 4S, 4, 3GS, 2G from an official source. You'll get a permanent iPhone unlock for any network and any iPhone model. We provide our ... unlock iphone 4s Unlock iPhone 4S up to iOS 6.1. Immediate download - Windows and Mac compatible. Free Lifetime Updates and Support. unlock iphone 4 Since the inception of iPhones on carriers, unlocking has been a mere fantasy which became true later on. In early days, everyone craved and ... unlock iphone 3gs Learn how to unlock your Apple iPhone 3GS. Compare across all free and paid options. Fully explained and rated. Impartial advice from our community.

Gurdeep Kaurbti said...

adult novelty gifts After something saucy, naughty and if possible, wildly inappropriate but hilarious? At FMAG we've a section for that! Peruse our adult novelty gifts today.

Gurdeep Kaurbti said...

futures market First of all, you need to understand the basics of analysis. Once you understand this, you can give a head start which will lead to greater profits. After learning the concepts, you need to go with the world. Understand the current trend and then trade according to the current trend. This will make us win the world. futures trading If you want to do futures trading, then please consider the following futures trading indicators before proceeding. forex trading online First of all, understand all the forex trading indicators and classify the indicators as high potential, medium potential and less potential. You should experience the art of managing these indicators in such a way that you get most out of the high potential indicators. But you should be aware that the high potential indicators will make you lose more money if you go wrong. Also, understand which trade is currently done by most of the people and follow that. forex trading indicators First of all, understand all the forex trading indicators and classify the indicators as high potential, medium potential and less potential. You should experience the art of managing these indicators in such a way that you get most out of the high potential indicators. But you should be aware that the high potential indicators will make you lose more money if you go wrong. Also, understand which trade is currently done by most of the people and follow that. eurusd trading Trading online is never a hassle with the penetration of software and technology. The biggest advantage of the technology is that it will compute tasks in such a way that the number of tasks is negligible. So, no matter how many factors you have to analyse in eurusd trading or how many currency pairs you are trading, you can analyse them very easily. fx trading indicators The next reason is the proficiency in trading concepts. Even though we may not know all concepts and fx trading indicators related to trading, we can do most of the analysis with the help of the software. futures trading indicators This will make you understand the situation whether to buy or to sell. As this is the main objective of trading, Bollinger bands help you to achieve the major objective of forex trading. This can also be considered as a confirmation tool in trading. fx trading signals This will make you understand the situation whether to buy or to sell. As this is the main objective of trading, Bollinger bands help you to achieve the major objective of forex trading. This can also be considered as a confirmation tool in trading. automated trading signals Even though the equity curve is a very powerful tool in analysing the automated trading signals, most people miss out in that because of the following factors. While choosing an indicator, you should make sure that the indicator is a valid indicator and it has useful data. Most people fail to do so. equity curve The other set of people use very powerful indicators with decent data. But they fail in choosing the number of indicators. If you are choosing a large number of indicators, then you will end up failing no matter how powerful your indicators are. So, choose the indicators with care if you want to succeed in trading.

somali music said...

http://www.bestcustomwriting.com/article-critique-help-tips-on-structure-and-format Students often think that when writing a math paper all they have to do is show their work, i.e., plop down the equations they used

Gurdeep Kaurbti said...

reebok military boots The latest styles of Reebok Work and Duty at unbeatable prices. Now Free Shipping on all Reebok boots.

somali music said...

ecift eCift.de: Türkische Singles mit Niveau - Europas grösste türkische Online-Partnervermittlung für anspruchsvolle türkische Singles. - eÇift ist Europas grösste ...

eçift said...

eçift eCift, a market-leading premium online partner agency in Turkey

Gurdeep Kaurbti said...

eçift eCift the leading platform in Turkey to match singles seeking long-term relationships. With the help of a personality test compatible matches based on key dimensions of personality are suggested that are scientifically proven to predict highly successful long-term relationships.

somali music said...

eçift eÇift is the leading premium online matchmaking and serious dating service in Turkey. Using a unique test, eÇift produces a personality profile for each of its members which enables the service to recommend potential partners to each other.

Connie Lingus said...

eçift eCift, a market-leading premium online partner agency in Turkey

ecift.com said...

eçift eCift the leading platform in Turkey to match singles seeking long-term relationships. With the help of a personality test compatible matches based on key dimensions of personality are suggested that are scientifically proven to predict highly successful long-term relationships.

ecift said...

eçift eCift the leading platform in Turkey to match singles seeking long-term relationships. With the help of a personality test compatible matches based on key dimensions of personality are suggested that are scientifically proven to predict highly successful long-term relationships.

ecift1.tumblr.com said...

eçift eCift the leading platform in Turkey to match singles seeking long-term relationships. With the help of a personality test compatible matches based on key dimensions of personality are suggested that are scientifically proven to predict highly successful long-term relationships.

ecift1.tumblr.com said...

eçift eÇift is the leading premium online matchmaking and serious dating service in Turkey. Using a unique test, eÇift produces a personality profile for each of its members which enables the service to recommend potential partners to each other.

http://ecift.blog.com/ said...

eçift eCift the leading platform in Turkey to match singles seeking long-term relationships. With the help of a personality test compatible matches based on key dimensions of personality are suggested that are scientifically proven to predict highly successful long-term relationships.

http://vimeo.com/53415273 said...

eçift eCift the leading platform in Turkey to match singles seeking long-term relationships. With the help of a personality test compatible matches based on key dimensions of personality are suggested that are scientifically proven to predict highly successful long-term relationships.

somali music said...

site comme oopad Le script ICPennyBid propose 2 types de ventes aux enchères : la vente aux enchères habituelle et la vente pour laquelle il faut acheter une place. Le gestionnaire du site gère les horaires, le pas d'enchère, formate la date, et définit tous les autres paramètres dans l'interface d'administration. Les paiements se font par PayPal ou par un autre processeur de paiement.

Gurdeep Kaurbti said...

Futur Digital To connect with Agence Web Futurdigital, sign up for Facebook today. ... N'hésitez pas à postuler ici : http://urls.fr/jsi et à en parler autour de vous ! ... réalisation par les équipes de graphistes, développeurs et référenceurs de Futur Digital : ...



cialis nedir said...

Cialis nedir derken misal iki-üç günlük bir tatile çıktınız sevgi. tatilin ilk sabahı bundan bir tane atıyorsunuz. tatil bitiminde http://www.cialisturkiye.net"sen insan değilsin." sözü ile karşılaştığınızda verdiğiniz paraya anlatıyor. dediğim gibi cinsel problemini gidermekten öte faydaları var. yalnız bokunu çıkartmayacaksın. senede bir bilemedin iki kez ve iki üç gün sen başa kalacağın zaman atacaksın bundan. öyle bir gecelik değil yani.

Andrew said...

Your blog article is very interesting and fantastic, at the same time the blog theme is unique and perfect, great job. To your success. One of the more impressive blogs I’ve seen. Thanks so much for keeping the internet classy for a change.
Andrew

Used Cars Colorado Springs said...

Just the project instructions I was looking for! All the instructions are clear and easy to follow and because I have *ahem* perfectionist tendencies, I needed to have everything laid out for me so I couldn't possibly make a mistake. Thank you! (Maybe when I finish my dresser I'll even let you take a peek for more click here Used Cars Colorado Springs

geciktirici sprey said...

Şimdi geciktirici sprey satın alırkende bunlara dikkat etmeniz gerekir. Aksi halde tam anlamı ile istenilen bilgiler bulunamaz. Ayrıca türkçe dil desteği de çok iyi olmalıdır.

alexa jeam said...

Nice post. I was checking constantly this blog and I’m impressed! Extremely useful info specially the last part I care for such information a lot. I was seeking this certain info for a long time. Thank you and good luck.
Best advertising Agency in the world | advertising agencies in Lahore | advertising agencies in Karachi